The Critic

A Vintage Murder Mystery with a Dark Bouquet

The Critic by Peter May is the second novel in the acclaimed Enzo Files series, blending gripping crime investigation with rich cultural detail. First published in 2007 by riverrun, this smart and atmospheric mystery takes readers deep into the heart of French wine country—where secrets ferment and murder is always on the menu.

Forensic expert Enzo Macleod is drawn into the chilling case of a renowned American wine critic found dead in a vat of fermenting grapes. The murder is gruesome, the setting idyllic, and the suspects plenty. As Enzo peels back layers of professional jealousy, family feuds, and regional rivalry, he uncovers a world where reputations are everything—and someone is willing to kill to protect theirs.

Peter May combines fast-paced plotting with lyrical prose and a strong sense of place. With Enzo’s sharp mind, flawed charm, and dry wit leading the way, The Critic is both a compelling whodunit and a celebration of French culture, wine, and food.

For Fans of Intelligent, International Crime Fiction

If you enjoy the atmospheric intrigue of Donna Leon or the forensic depth of Patricia Cornwell, The Critic is a must-read. It’s a murder mystery with body, complexity, and a finish that lingers long after the final page.